Wines of the Week
Second Labels -- And Who Makes Them
Second Labels – The Best-Kept Secret
We all want to enjoy great wine, but not all of us want to fork over a mortgage payment for a big Bordeaux or Super Tuscan. Fortunately, there are less expensive alternatives.
I suppose there are people who drink major bottles as an everyday matter. A thousand dollars to them is like ten dollars to the rest of us. Just a matter of scale and proportion. But those people don’t live at our house.
We divide our meager collection into maybe three parts…
· Everyday drinking wines, like the corks we pop when we get home from work after a bad day…or any kind of day. These are generally under $25-$20 a bottle.
· Somewhat special wines that we’ll enjoy if some part of our lives has gone exceptionally well that day or week. Something like we signed a new client.
· The collectibles…wines we’ve purchased over the years that have increased insanely in value. These we open only to celebrate anniversaries, births, or in the company of people who open similar bottles for us.
But it’s still possible to find and enjoy high quality wines made by globally famous wineries. They’re called second and even third labels.
World class wineries such as ChateauMargaux or Screaming Eagle carefully sort their grapes by hand during harvest. Since grapes don’t ripen evenly in bunches, this is a painstaking and laborious process. The first quality grapes are selected for the major label.
The remaining grapes are sorted again, and the best ones are retained and vinified for the second label, which is sold at a fraction of the price. For example, a bottle of 2005 Chateau Margaux, a Grand Cru Bordeaux, costs around $700. Their second label, Pavillon Rouge du Chateau Margaux, is going for about $170. Not cheap, but not completely outrageous.
Here’s a bit of help for when you’re ready to buy something really nice, but not insanely priced, for that birthday, anniversary, or holiday.
The most highly-prized and expensive Bordeaux wines have second labels, such as the above-mentioned Pavillon Rouge du Chateau Margaux, Carruades de Lafite, Les Forts de LaTour, and La Mission Haut Brion. Other well-known Bordeaux producers offer second labels such as Echo de Lynch-Bages. There are many others, as well.
In America, things are a bit different. Wineries generally make several wines in many price categories. There is Caymus, which is a reasonably priced California Cabernet at about $65. Then there’s Caymus “Special Selection,” which will set you back over $250.
The Italians are especially good at this, so watch for these comparative bargains, and sample a few on those occasions that call for something a bit more special.
Until then, here’s just the kind of second label to look for:
Le Volte dell’Ornellaia Red Blend Tuscany 2015 ($30) – The top wine from Ornellaia sells for around $250 a bottle, so this is one of their value labels…and it is a value. Dark ruby color in the glass with interesting aromas of milk chocolate and faint pine. Dark red plum on the palate, along with wet stones and bright mixed fruit. Very drinkable young, and great wine for the price. WW 90
Also from Ornellaia, there’s Le Serre Nuove ($75)…a bit higher priced, but this wine has outscored even the top Bordeaux in competitive tastings for many years. Medium ruby color with lots of red berries and fine, silky tannins. WW 95
Lucente 2014 ($18)…is a great value. This “super Tuscan” is a blend of Sangiovese and Merlot and the new oak aging gives it black cherry, vanilla, and coffee aromas and flavors. WW 90
Ask the Wine Whisperer
A restaurant we went to had "Draft Wine" on the list. I had never heard of it so I ordered a cab/syrah/merlot blend called Triple Threat. The waiter didn’t know what draft was or the winery this came from. It was surprisingly pleasant. Have you heard of draft wines before? Marna L., Seattle
Some very prestigious wineries are now putting their wine in kegs for use in restaurant by-the-glass service. This preserves the wine much better than leaving opened half-bottles standing around, and does not affect quality. I wouldn’t be hesitant to order a draft wine anywhere it’s offered.
Great Wines from Unusual Places
In the Mood for Moldova
One of the most fascinating things about the world of wine is that it…well, covers the world. Example: I guess we can be excused if we can’t instantly find the country of Moldova on a map (it’s sandwiched between Romania to the east and Ukraine, just off the Black Sea), but we recently received some sample wines from there, and guess what. They‘re worth a sip. And a second.
To have a viable wine industry, a country needs a stable central government, an institution which had been sadly lacking in that area until fairly recently. But now winemakers are free to take advantage of their soils and climate and bring some interesting and previously unknown varietals to the market. Moldova has over 275,000 acres of land under vine, so they’re not exactly new at this, and they’re cultivating both familiar international grapes and some that are very indigenous.
We sampled the Asconi Feteasca 2014 and were pleasantly rewarded. This grape grows as both a white and a red, but our enjoyment came from the white. It’s a light straw color with aromas of fruits and flowers, mainly white peach. The palate is sour apple, jasmine and a nice zingy acidity. We liked it. WW 89.
The “Other” Bordeaux
On the east side of the Gironde River, or the Right Bank, there are several well known appellations, including St. Emilion and Pomerol. But some growers from lesser-known areas deserve recognition, and they know it. So they’ve banded together to create an overall “brand” for wines that come from areas such as Castillon (southeast of St. Emilion) and the areas of Bourg and Blaye, directly across the river from Margaux. Sure, we all think of the famous grand cru wines like Lafite, Petrus, and others, but there are bargains – and great taste experiences – to be found in many, many other areas. Here are some of our recent discoveries.
Château Moulin de Clotte Castillon 2010 -- This blend of 90% Merlot and 10% Cabernet Franc gives off a nose of earth and minerals, followed by flavors dark earth and black fruit. A bit tannic, so needs time or a good decanting. WW 89-90
Château Roland La Garde Blaye Côtes de Bordeaux 2010 – Earth and smoke on the nose with flavors that are very true to type. Unmistakably a Bordeaux. Made in a lighter style, it’s ready to drink today. WW 90
Château de Francs “Les Cerisiers” Côtes de Bordeaux 2009—In French, cerisiers means “cherry blossoms.” The wine is well named. Inky black in the glass, it certainly offers aromas of dark cherry. On the palate, the black cherry pays off with just a hint of oak. Another blend of mostly Merlot, it’s still tannic and needs time or food. WW 90-91
We’re painfully aware that some of the wines we review may not be available locally, but they’re all worth the search. Even though I like to support my local wine merchants, and I always look around here first, you might consider visiting www.wine-searcher.com. This website gives you a list of retailers that have your wine in stock. Click on their link, order online, and they’ll deliver it right to your home or office. Hint: if you order now, ask them to hold your purchase for delivery in October or November, when the weather cools off.
Ask the Wine Whisperer
“We’re seeing a lot of arguments in print about wine bottles sealed with corks vs. screw tops. Which is better?” Jim M., North Fort Myers
This is an argument that probably will never subside. Cork is, after all, an organic product – the bark of a certain type of oak tree. It breaks down over time, and worst of all, is subject to a fungus called TCA that robs the wine of its freshness or spoils it completely. Screw caps (the makers would prefer that we call them “twist-offs”), seal a bottle completely, and most likely can last forever.
Volumes have been written on this topic, but I’d say that wines you’re planning on drinking over the next few years are perfectly fine with a “twist off.” The more expensive wines will likely still be sealed with corks, at least for the immediate future.
What Makes a Wine "Natural"?
Natural Wines – The Next Big Thing
There’s a reason why so-called “natural” wines are making such a big impression these days. Mostly, it’s an indication of the overall trend for foods and lifestyles that are closer to the earth. Non-GMO products, all-natural ingredients, yoga, and the like.
One Florida resident is betting the farm (so to speak) on the quality and appeal of natural wines. He’s Peter Rizzo, and his new store, Natural Wines Naples, is educating both wine lovers and newbies to the flavors and appeal of natural wines.
More about Peter in a second, but first let’s figure out what natural wines really are. Basically, they’re made in the purest, simplest way possible. Vineyards are organic or even biodynamic. Winemakers use only naturally-occurring yeasts to induce fermentation – no addition of other yeast strains.
Plus, the winemaking is what’s known as “non-interventionist.” That means no filtering, no additives, no manipulation. Grow the grapes, crush them, and let nature take its course.
“These wines have a place on every wine lover’s shelf,” says Peter Rizzo. “They’re very expressive, and a lot more interesting than wines made in a more commercial manner. I really believe in this.” And so do I, after the tasting session we shared.
Even though natural wines are something of uncharted territory for most of us, there are plenty of reasons to get to know them. These winemakers believe that great wine is made in the vineyard. The growing areas are free from any insecticides, pesticides, herbicides or other chemicals. The wines are made without any additives, no extra acid or flavoring compounds, no industrial yeasts or enzymes, and extremely minimal sulfur content. There’s no weird manipulation, like micro-oxygenation, reverse osmosis, or concentrators. As you might expect, vineyard yields are low, so quantities are not very high.
The result: wines that are alive, that express a sense of place, and that improve – quickly – over time.
Rizzo, who spent most of his career in advertising, relocated with his family to Naples in 2002 and opened Natural Wines Naples in October of 2016. Since then, he’s seen a steady increase in interest, and in store traffic. While some natural wines are made from fairly exotic out-of-the-way varietals (I saw a bottle of Romortin and Orbois blend), you’d recognize the vast majority of wines in his extensive selection.
“I need to show people classic representations,” he believes. “Even though many makers of natural wines push the envelope with non-traditional varietals, we have all the classic wines, and all the classic flavors. Just because a wine is natural, it doesn’t sacrifice the familiar taste profiles we all enjoy.”
He makes sure of that, with extensive descriptions of each wine’s flavor and aroma profiles on bottle tags that he hand-writes. And he’s especially proud of the fact that his wine selection offers interesting choices in all price ranges.
“There’s nothing rare or exotic about natural wines,” says Rizzo. “You might be surprised to see some bottles with crown caps on them instead of corks, and we do have some wines made from grapes you may not be familiar with, but you’ll find all your favorites here, with many priced under $20.”
He was kind enough to offer me samples of his selection in several price ranges, and the quality was striking. Here are some we especially enjoyed.
Les Quarterons Sancerre 2013 ($30) – A sweet floral nose, completely unlike traditional Sauvignon Blanc from this region or New Zealand, with flavors of apple, peach, and quince. WW 90
Skeveldra Sancerre 2012 ($42) – Absolutely zero sulfites in this zippy, fragrant version. Exotic floral, lemon, apricot, and vanilla aromas and flavors. I’ve never decanted a white wine, but I’d give this one an hour or two in the glass before sipping. WW 91
Donkey & Goat White Blend California 2014 ($35) – As mentioned above, some makers of natural wines stray a bit off the reservation. This is a blend of Vermentino, Grenache Blanc, Picpoul, and a few other northern Rhone varietals with interesting flavors of red apple peel, yellow peach, and cantaloupe. A boldly structured white. WW 92.
New Favorites for Summer
So much wine, so little time...
One of the things I like best about being a wine columnist is the opportunity to sample and review the gratifying number of sample bottles that show up in my office from time to time. Recently, I called together a few friends who have great palates (and great wine collections) and asked them to help me sample through about 20 or so bottles that have been waiting forlornly in my cellar for me to open them and swirl, sniff, and sip. Although everyone, of course, has different tastes and likes and dislikes, we were all pretty much in agreement that these wines were worth looking for and enjoying.
They should be in fairly wide distribution, so if you try any, let me know how you liked them. Cheers!
Ciù Ciù Passerina Evoè Marche 2015 ($7) – This wine would be a steal at three times the price. The Passerina grape is an ancient white varietal, not seen much these days. In fact, it was new to me. The nose offers fragrant flowers and cantaloupe, with similar flavors on the palate. Highly recommended. WW 89+
Scacciadiavoli Montefalco Sagrantino 2008 ($32) – A rich, powerful Sagrantino with a nose of leather, smoke, and deep black fruit. The palate of dried plums, prunes, and chocolate goes on forever through an amazing finish. Killer stuff. WW 92
Fontanafredda Barolo 2012 ($46) – Possibly the most translucent Barolo we’ve ever seen. Pleasant
Matanzas Creek Merlot Sonoma 2013 ($30) – A full-bodied effort, dark ruby in the glass and bold aromas of chocolate and red fruit. Very fruit forward, and certainly a great food wine. WW 90-91
Avignonesi Rosso di Montalcino 2014 ($17) – This “baby Brunello” would be great with grilled meats. Medium-bodied on the palate, flavors of red currant, cherry, and violets. WW 89
Concannon Petite Sirah 2014 ($11) – Great value, and a steal at the price. A big, dark, black wine in the glass, it delivers aromas of warm earth and smoke, but fruit flavors on the palate. You’ll enjoy the complexity of the blackberry, raspberry, black pepper, baking chocolate and mushroom. Lovely. WW 89-90.
Bousquet Malbec Tupungato Valley Mendoza Grande Riserva 2013 ($25) – A wine that’s very much about the place and the soil…an Old World style. Bold flavors of earth, truffle, and black tobacco. WW 88
Kendall-Jackson Chardonnay Grand Reserve 2015 ($14) -- From the middle-range of the KJ portfolio, this is a great everyday sipper. Medium bodied, with balanced oak notes supporting apple and lemon flavors. WW 87-88
Meomi Chardonnay California 2015 ($13) – Grapes are blended from three very diverse regions in this wine. It’s bold and creamy with a buttery mouthfeel and an entertaining hint of buttered popcorn. Straightforward flavors of pear and white peach. WW 88
Wine We Loved in 2016
2016 in Review....
Here's a compilation of favorite reviewed wines from 2016. They're generally available, so we hope you can find and enjoy them.
Grgich Hills Estate Merlot Napa Valley 2012 – Medium dark in the glass, there is a definite floral aroma on the nose. Maybe roses. For a young wine, it’s very drinkable, with soft tannins, and overtones of strawberries, cherries, and a hint of licorice. WW 90
Vanderbilt Reserve Merlot Dry Creek Valley 2013 – The opaque and inky color in the glass hints at a full-bodied wine. There is sweet dark fruit on the nose, but it’s very tight on the palate and needs a lot of time (or really aggressive decanting) to open up. Attractive flavors of red cherry, a bit of earth, and graphite. WW 89
Desiderio Cortona DOC Merlot 2014 – This effort from Italy is a bit lighter in color, but still delivers full-bodied aromas of cedar, earthiness, spice, and dark fruit. The spice pays off on the palate, with cinnamon, clove, and black fruit flavors. WW 92
Meerlust Merlot Stellenbosch 2008 – This South Africans are at it again with their interpretation of this international varietal. Even though it’s semi-translucent in the glass, there are plentiful flavors of raspberry, black cherry, tobacco, and leather. A very Old World interpretation. We drank the whole bottle. WW 92-93
Kendall Jackson Vintner’s Reserve Sauvignon Blanc California 2014 – Pale yellow in the glass, and on the nose and palate it’s definitely not the typical New Zealand style. There are aromas of lemony minerality with bright tropical fruit on the palate supported by zingy acidity. About $13. WW 88
Stift Skellerei Newstift Abbazia di Novacella Sylvaner 2014 – If you can pronounce it, they should give you a bottle for free. But this is one of the surprises I mentioned above. The Sylvaner grape is grown way up north in Italy, right along the German border where the cultures and languages mix freely. This wine comes from a winery that dates back to the year 1142, with green apple flavors and a strong spine of acidity making this a good pairing with fish and other seafood dishes. WW 88
Landmark Vineyards Overlook Chardonnay Sonoma 2013 – One of those pleasant discoveries. It’s light gold yellow with a layered nose of oak, lemon, honey and white flowers. A rich, mouthfilling Chardonnay with oak overtones and a medium finish. WW 91-92
Trinity Hill Hawke’s Bay Pinot Noir 2013 – Another surprise. Usually, the Pinot Noirs from New Zealand come from the Central Otago region on the south island, but this producer is in Hawke’s Bay, which is on the east coast of the North Island. The wine is translucent ruby-violet with a definite old world nose of loamy earth and graphite. But it offers new world flavors of raspberry, blueberry, strawberry, and smoke. Nice. WW 90-91
Blair Pinot Noir Arroyo Seco Delfina’s Vineyard 2012 – This version tilts more toward the new world, with lovely flavors of strawberry, raspberry, and cedar. WW 89
Domaine Gardies Cotes du Roussillon-Villages Les Milleres– Plum, raspberry and plenty of red currant with a firm tannic structure. Should age well.
Cave de Roquebrun Coteaux du Languedoc Terrasses du Frigoulet 2011 – Don’t let the polysyllabic name scare you off. This one is powerful and concentrated, with plum, cherry pie, and dark chocolate. It should be widely available.
M. Chapoutier Cotes du Roussillon-Villages Les Vignes de Bila Haut 2010 – Chapoutier is a major quality producer. This bottling was aWine Spectator Top 100 selection, it costs $13, and they made 35,000 cases.
Watch for more reviews and recommendations coming soon!
Red Table Wine -- Only $250 a Bottle
Red Table Wine. Only $250 a Bottle.
Seems a little steep, doesn’t it, to pay over $100 for a bottle of something that says “table wine” or just “red wine” on the label. It isn’t one of those rare blockbuster California cabernets, or a precious vintage from the sacred vineyards of Burgundy. It’s just…well, red table wine.
But wait. Take a closer look at where it’s from, and what’s inside the bottle, because that humble title can conceal a drinking experience that’s well worth the price. And more.
Most likely, the label you’re looking at comes from Italy, or some other ancient winemaking area that’s steeped in long tradition and strict custom. So if you’re confused about what’s in the bottle, you can thank the Italian government. Over the years, they passed a whole spate of laws defining specific wine zones in the country, decreeing what kind of “recipe” each wine should conform to, how long it should be aged, all that. Unfortunately, they forgot one thing: the most innovative winemakers make not want to follow the ancient recipes.
Say you’re sitting out there in your vineyard in the middle of Chianti, a few miles from Castellina or some other ancient winemaking center, and you just don’t want to make your wine the way the Official Recipe demands. Maybe you’re feeling puckish and you throw in a little of that cabernet you’ve been growing, or a couple of Merlot grapes. You’ve got a problem. Follow the traditional recipe, and you can call your wine Chianti. Don’t, and you can’t.
There’s no official name for wines that don’t conform, so what do you call it? Probably, you’d call it a Super Tuscan, which is exactly what the major producers, over the past decade or so, have done.
In the most popular – and expensive – Super Tuscans, sangiovese is still the major component, and the wine serves as a sensational accent to all kinds of traditional Italian cuisines. The rest (there are maybe about 20) are made from merlot, cabernet sauvignon, syrah, and other international varietals. As I said, wines from Chianti that do not follow the rules don’t have an official terminology. What’s worse, they get classified in the lowest designation of quality, which is called IGT, down there with the $8 bottles. The lack of an official name for nonconforming wine has driven producers to make up clever names of their own, all of which contain lots of vowels. There’s Ornellaia, which is made primarily from cabernet sauvignon. And Tignanello, which is mostly sangiovese. Then there’s the wine that is said to have started the whole Super Tuscan revolution, Sassicaia, made from cabernet sauvignon and aged and barreled differently from any other Chianti regional wine up to its time.
While Super Tuscans like Solaia, Summus, or Fontalloro may cost well over a Franklin apiece, some are priced a little more mercifully. My bargain favorite, Monte Antico, is made mostly from sangiovese, but not entirely, and costs under $15 a bottle. While it can’t compare to the juice that Marchese Antinori is putting in his Tignanello bottles, it’s a nice step away from your typical Chianti, and it’s absolutely sensational with pizza.
It’s easy to become a dedicated Italian wine lover. Just pick up a decent Tuscan blend like Monte Antico (great value at around $10),Terrabianca Campaccio ($25),orBalzini ($20), which has white label, red label, and black label versions, each indicating a different blend. For pasta and pizza, it’s the way to go.
Ask the Wine Whisperer
In the bottom of a bottle of white wine, I saw some clear crystals. What are they? Has the wine gone bad? Ron H., Fort Lauderdale
Wines contain many types of acid. The crystals you’re seeing are actually bits of solidified tartaric acid, or plain old cream of tartar, which is tasteless and harmless. Sometimes you also find them at the inside end of a cork. The wine is fine to drink, but don’t eat the crystals.